Freedom of opinion vs. freedom of assembly

Disappointing news for those who believe in the freedom of expressing opinion: On February 15, 2006 the Court of Pest County (Pest Megyei Bíróság) delivered its final judgment about the two activists of MIEP- Jobbik for holding an unannounced press conference in front of the Ministry of the Interior last summer.

The “unannounced” press conference was disrupted and dismissed by the police. The reason for disrupting the crowd of two people according to the police was that if an assembly is unannounced it must be dismissed, without regard to the reason of the assembly. Unfortunately, seemingly this reasoning is accepted by the court as well.

The Hungarian Civil Liberties Union would like to emphasize again that the freedom of expressing opinion is one of the most significant institutions of a democratic state. In our opinion to terminate a two member press conference held on the street for it has not been announced at the police 72 hours before it starts, does not stands for the democratic standards.

This unfortunate precedent may result in becoming an obstacle for small political groups or civil organizations to react in timely manner and forming quick press conferences on the street if needed. Those who are attracted to conspiracy theories might raise the question whether the bigger political parties announce their press conferences held on the streets as well. According to the opinion of the activists in question, the answer to this question is: no.


Related articles

Press Release: Meeting of High Commissioner of Police and President of HCLU

On August 7th, 2007 Dr. Bencze József, Liutenant General High Comissioner of Hungarian National Police invited Balázs Dénes, President of the HCLU and his colleagues to a meeting at the National Police Headquarters. For results of this meeting, please read the below press release.

Social Protest and Human Rights - Discussion

The International Network of Civil Liberties Organizations (INCLO) invites you to a discussion on police use of force and human rights' protections in social protests. The UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions, Christof Heyns, and the UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights to Freedom of Peaceful Assembly and of Association, Maina Kiai, are addressing these issues in their annual reports and will explain the challenges we are facing.

Court dismissed the complaint of the 7. District’s Local Government, Budapest

On 30 Nov, 2006 the court’s judgment was made in favor of HCLU, representing Peter Marinov, former leader of ÓVÁS! Association against the 7. District.