Letter to the Minister of Justice and Law Enforcement

The HCLU has written a letter to Tibor Draskovics, Hungarian Minister of Justice and Law Enforcement, to question why private security services were allowed to check identities and search the clothing of citizens during the March 15th National State Ceremonies.

dr. Tibor Draskovics
Minister of Justice and Law Enforcement

Dear Mr.Minister,

It has come to our attention through media reportings that during the March 15th, 2008 State Ceremonies, In-Kal security guards behaved in a manner associated with police measures. Specifically, checking identities, searching the clothing of, and confiscating various items from citizens practicing their right to assembly in Budapest. All this, in the presence of the police. According to media reports, employees and contractors of this economic group received 5.95 million Hungarian forints for this activity.

We kindly ask Mr.Minister to inform us of the following:

- What specific activities did the employees of In-Kal Security conduct during the securing of the March 15th, State Ceremony sites (National Museum and vicinity)? On what orders or specific terms of reference were they acting upon?

- How many persons were involved in securing the event sites on behalf of the private security service? How many citizens were exposed to their activities?

- Did the employees of the security service in fact check identities and search clothing of citizens or conduct any other actions associated with police measures? If so, on what legal grounds?

- Did the police co-operate with the security service? If so, who was the contact person? If not, did any member of any police organizational unit witness these activities? If so, what measures were taken regarding the activities of the security service? If none were taken, what was the reason for it?

Further to the above mentioned data, in accordance with the 1992. LXII. Act on Personal Data Protection and Freedom of Information, the HCLU kindly requests a copy of the contract and appendixes, written directions and orders serving as basis of the above mentioned activity with relation to the March 15th events to be sent to our offices or e-mail address.

Sincerely,

Balázs Dénes
Executive Director
Hungarian Civil Liberties Union

Share

Related articles

Invitation to HCLU Press Conference

The HCLU will hold a press conference on findings of police practices during September and October 23rd, 2006

Social Protest and Human Rights - Discussion

The International Network of Civil Liberties Organizations (INCLO) invites you to a discussion on police use of force and human rights' protections in social protests. The UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions, Christof Heyns, and the UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights to Freedom of Peaceful Assembly and of Association, Maina Kiai, are addressing these issues in their annual reports and will explain the challenges we are facing.

Litigation on the right to protest

Two actions were launched by the HCLU regarding the right to peaceful assembly in December, 2013. Both actions concern to the same problem: lockdown of a public area around the Prime Minister's residence. In the first case, the police dispersed an ongoing peaceful demonstration on the grounds of closing off the area, for which the organizer filed a claim against the police with the help of HCLU. In the other case, another demonstration planned by the same organizer at the same venue was banned by the court, which was then challenged before the Constitutional Court. Both decisions are ill-unfounded and misinterpret the constitutional limitations of the right to protest.