Report on a FOI lawsuit against the Atomic Energy Authority

The HCLU together with seven other environmental and legal defence NGOs sued the Hungarian Atomic Energy Authority (HAEA) as it has refused to present data of public interest. The first court hearing was on 25th February 2005.

10th April 2003 a serious derangement has occured at the Paks Nuclear Power Plant, the 2nd unit of the plant was stalled and it was restarted 3rd September 2004. The eight NGOs tried to gain insight into the documentation on which the restart decision was based, but the HAEA stated that these document are not of public interest. According to the Hungarian Data Protection and Freedom of Information Act if someone’s application for data of public interest is refused the data processing organ can be sued for publishing the information.

The eight NGOs filed their petition on the 22nd September 2004. The first court hearing was today. In the Hungarian FOI law the burden of proof that the refusal was lawful and well-founded lies with the data processing organ. The HAEA states that the expertise is under the protection of intellectual property law and it is a business secret. Furthermore they claim it is data for internal use and data prepared in connection with decision making, which shall not be public within 20 years. At the first hearing the HAEA has not made a motion for proving their statements.

The next court hearing will be on 1st of April.

Share

Related articles

Supreme Court Decision – Data on Budapest’s CCTV Is to Be Made Public

The important lesson in this case is that even though hundreds of cameras are monitoring our lives day and night, the police still do not have any evidence backing up the effectiveness of the CCTV in crime prevention. At least the Supreme Court, in it’s decision, has given back a piece of our right to personal privacy by making public when and where CCTVs are watching, thus we will be less at the mercy of those watching us. On the basis of public interest data, it will be easier to judge the price we have to pay for the promise of public safety.

A case against Ministry of Finance

HCLU filed a case on 4 September against the Ministry of Finance for not releasing information on a billion HUF deficit in the budget of 2006.

Secret Microsoft-Ministry Contracts Worth Billions

In the summer of 2006, the HCLU turned to the Ministry of Economy and Transportation and the Ministry of Justice and Law Enforcement requesting public interest data on the billions worth of contracts between the ministries and Microsoft.