The First Map of Budapest CCTVs Is Available Online

After two and a half years of litigations, the Supreme Court has reached its final verdict. Budapest Police Headquarters is ordered to issue data on the CCTV systems operated by the police in Budapest. Locations, and all information regarding the operational, financial, technical, legal and personnel aspects, as well as informing of the public and monitoring data is now considered public interest data.

Out of the 600 cameras operating in Budapest, more than 300 can be found on the map of www.geospace.hu. The Geospace.hu project has helped in the creation of the map free of charge, but to have a complete picture, we ask for the help of the public. Mark on the map where cameras can be found, take pictures of them and upload these to the map. Since in a few districts (X. and XIII.) cameras are unlawfully operated by others than the police, there is no available data on those. The HCLU has initiated, and won lawsuits against those districts in first instance decisions.

There is very little data available on CCTV systems, so we can only be sure of three things:

1. The CCTV restricts citizens from practicing their right to informational autonomy

2. The necessity and proportionality (constitutionality) of the CCTV is not supported by anything, as no study has ever been completed in Hungary on the effects the cameras have on crime, or whether there are other means -namely ones that don’t squelch on people’s privacy- of reducing crime.

3. CCTVs are exteremely expensive. In Zugló (a district of Budapest), 68 cameras were installed in 2006 for 160 million forints. Operational costs also come to millions of forints each year.

By creating the map, the goal of the HCLU and geospace.hu was to inform the public about where and how they are being watched.

The HCLU would like to raise awareness and would like to advance, that citizens are not kept in the dark regarding these restrictions costing millions. Through the Internet, citizens will noe be able to monitor those monitoring them.

 

Share

Related articles

NGOs Reject "Safe Harbor 2.0," Urge EU and US to Protect Fundamental Rights

Leading human rights and consumer organizations have issued a letter to urge the US and the EU to protect the fundamental right to privacy.

Repeal of Hungarian Communications Act Gets Amicus Support

Open Rights Group, Privacy International and internationally renowned experts file amicus curiae briefs with the Hungarian Constitutional Court in a case to repeal the country's communications act.

Call for urgent amicus briefs!

In April 2014 the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) declared invalid the Data Retention Directive that unified the rules of the retention of selective data by Internet and telephone services and determined the accessibility of data by authorities in the member states. Despite the content of the judgment, the Hungarian act allowing data retention is still in force. In October, 2014 the HCLU started litigation against two major service providers in order to force the Hungarian Constitutional Court (CC) to repeal the unlawful act.