There is No Effective Control Over National Security - Three Civil Organizations File Complaints with the Constitutional Court

The Eötvös Károly Institute, the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union, and Transparency International Hungary seek to jointly challenge the new Act on the protection of classified information, promulgated on April 1st, and several provisions of the Act on national security before the Constitutional Court.

The petition highlights four ways in which the Act threatens the constitutional operation of the national security sector:
1. The classification of information (previously called state secrets or service secrets) is the most powerful restriction on the right of access to information of public interest. The Act on classified information does not assure that information can be classified only when it is necessary, and does not prevent abuse by persons seeking toprevent violations of law and corruption from being detected or to protect the reputation of an organization.
2. The new Act does not provide an effective legal remedy in court to access classified information. Additionally, it does not specify whether judges can examine the reasonableness of the classification, or if judges are limited to examining whether or not the documents have been marked “Secret.”
3. The rules on national security supervision set forth in the Act on national security further weaken the monitoring of Hungarian intelligence agencies. The members of the parliamentary committees for national security and defense, and the justices who preside over cases where classified data is handled, have to pass a national security vetting. The vetting does not only examine the reliability of the individual who is going handle the classified data, but also whether this individual can be blackmailed and through what means. The vetting is performed by the National Security Office, and eventually the monitored committee members and judges would have the role controlling the National Security Office.
4. The legislator turned the application of the criminal sanctions for abuse of classified information totally unpredictable, by giving the exclusive authority to initiate criminal procedure in such cases to the originator of the information. Therefore there is a high risk that criminal enforcement may become servant of political interests.
The activities of the intelligence agencies are the least transparent of any Hungarian public body. For this reason, there is a particularly strong need to closely monitor whether the agencies use their power legitimately and accordingly with the values of the rule of law.
The three organizations used arguments similar to these when they petitioned to the President of the Hungarian Republic to initiate an ex ante examination of the Act’s constitutionality at the Constitutional Court in December of 2009. Their petitions left unanswered, the three organizations now argue that the Act is unconstitutional. The three organizations have initiated their current proceeding before the Constitutional Court, and expect that the Constitutional Court will quickly decide to request the legislature to pass constitutional amendments to these laws.

Share

Related articles

Government to Abolish Regulation on Lobbying – the Anti-corruption Institutions are About to Weaken

The draft Bill on Social Participation will repeal the now operative law on lobbying. This proposed measure would lead to an increase in oppurtunities for corruption by curtailing the transparency of public decision-making.

The Agreement Between the Hungarian Tax and Financial Control Administration (APEH) and Business Software Alliance (BSA) Has to

On Friday the HCLU have called upon the APEH to make public the cooperation agreement with BSA on the grounds of public interest data. The document was made accessible on the internet, even though previously the APEH stated that ’by unwritten law, such documents contain an obligation of secrecy, thus the original text will not be made public on the APEH’s webpage’.

HCLU proposes Open Government Partnership commitments

The goal of the Open Government Partnership (OGP) initiated by American President Barack Obama is the establishment of a transparent, efficient and accountable government/administration. The HCLU and K-Monitor have prepared proposals on commitments to be undertaken by Hungary.