Court of the first instance denied our petition against the Budapest Police Department

The Central District Court of Pest denied the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union's (HCLU) petition against Budapest Police Department (Budapesti Rendőr Főkapitányság) for the disclosure of the data of public interest regarding the camera systems installed in several districts of Budapest.

We submitted a questionnaire to the local police departments in the spring of 2004. The questionnaire contained 80 questions enquiring about the conditions and circumstances of operating the camera systems. The Budapest Police Department responded to our questions.

Unfortunately many of our questions had been unanswered. According to the police, if they gave answers to all of our questions they would jeopardize crime investigation purposes. In HCLU’s view all the questions of the questionnaire were aimed at and related to data of public interest. Therefore, we filed an action against the Budapest Police Department at the court for disclosure of data of public interest.

It took one year for the court to schedule the first hearing and than the court of first instance denied our petition.

The curiosity of the case is that previously we have asked the same questions regarding the same issue from local governments in Budapest and also on the countryside. Against many of them we filed petitions as well for the disclosure of data of public interest. We settled with the local government of Terézváros before the first hearing. The local government disclosed the required data and HCLU withdrew the petition. We won the lawsuit against the city of Székesfehérvár and the city disclosed the data as well. HCLU won the lawsuit against Újpest as well, however the local government of Újpest has not provided us with the required data yet.

 

Share

Related articles

Performance on International Freedom of Information Day

On Sepetember 28th, International Freedom of Information Day is celebrated in 40 countries worldwide. This year, it is celebrated in Hungary for the first time, organized by the HCLU during the Week of Civil Awareness.

Half the Battle Won in the “Nuclear” Lawsuit

The Court of Appeals sent the case back to the Metropolitan Court because the court of first instance was wrong in defining the expert opinions regarding the re-start of the Paks Nuclear Power Plant’s 2nd block were not public data. The Court of Appeals ruled that indeed they were public data, but it was possible that they were to be considered as trade secrets or fell under copyright laws. This however needed to be decided by the court of first instance in a re-trial.

Landmark decision on freedom of information by the European Court of Human Rights

The Hungarian Civil Liberties Union won a freedom of information case against the Republic of Hungary. For the first time, the right to access to state-held information as part of Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights has been formally recognized, as reflected in today’s ruling by the European Court of Human Rights. The Strasbourg based Court declared that withholding information needed to participate in public debate on matters of public importance may violate the freedom of expression.