HCLU Wins Landmark Freedom of Information Case

The Hungarian Ministry of Development and Economics is ordered to disclose data, which reveal what investments worth 200 billion Hungarian forints – nearly 800 million euros - were carried out by Swedish companies in exchange for the purchase of Gripen fighter-jets by the Hungarian Air Force. The journalist of on-line newspaper, origo.hu – with legal representation provided by the HCLU - has initiated a Freedom of Information lawsuit in December, 2007, because the Ministry has previously rejected to provide information to the journalist’s FOI request. According to the September 8th ruling of the Regional Court of Appeals, the defendant Ministry acted unlawfully.

In 2001, the government decided on purchasing the Swedish Gripen-jets instead of the American F-16 jets for the Hungarian Air Force. In compliance with the contracts, 110% of the purchase price had to be invested in Hungary by the Swedish party or rather, had to be used to create opportunities of export-expansion to Sweden for Hungarian companies. Two years later, the following administration ordered more advanced jets and increased the purchase price to nearly its double.

In mid-August 2008, the Saab/Gripen Group issued a press release, which states that it fulfilled its duties – worth almost 800 million euros - according to the contract. The original term, cited from the 2001 contract, was due to end in 2015. Also ascertained from the press release was, that this was approved by the Ministry’s Offset Committee on March 27th, 2008. The journalist represented by the HCLU filed the lawsuit in December, 2007, because that is when the Offset Committee has informed the public, that more than 90% of the offset has been fulfilled.

The object of the lawsuit was to find out what Swedish investments were accounted by the Ministry. According to the first and second instance rulings, the requested data could shed light on this.

The Regional Court of Appeals’ decision states, that the requested data is unequivocally public interest data since the fighter-jets were purchased from public funds and the data requested by the journalist are closely connected to the acquirements. The verdict states that the Ministry is obligated to issue the exact list of companies, which received shares from the offset program.

According to the Ministry’s files – to which the Ministry’s lawyers referred to during trial - there are approximately 80 such companies.

The HCLU considers the verdict to be of great significance and hopes the Ministry will disclose the requested data. In this case, the Hungarian government is litigating the public by rejecting to disclose data regarding the government’s nearly 800 million euro spending. The HCLU expects the Ministry - after the first and second instance verdicts – to keep from turning to the Supreme Court for an extra-ordinary remedy.

Share

Related articles

Hungary's Weak New Anti-Corruption Program

The Hungarian government has devised a new anti-corruption program, which, as opposed to reducing corruption, in fact increases the government's power. Compared with earlier plans, reforms concerning the financing of parties and the protection of whistleblowers have been excluded from the program, which also fails to deal with the asset declarations of MPs. The civil and the business sectors, in turn, are facing stricter regulations in the future.

Hungary Classifies All Information Regarding Paks Nuclear Plant

Five NGOs, including the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union, have addressed an open letter to Hungary's president after the draft law on the maintenance of the Paks Nuclear Power Plant was passed by the Parliament. The NGOs demand that President János Áder initiate a constitutional review of the law before the Constitutional Court. The NGOs are concerned because the new act severely limits access to public interest data by rendering all information concerning the Paks plant as classified data for the next 30 years. Opposition parties have joined the organizations in attacking the decision.

HCLU proposes Open Government Partnership commitments

The goal of the Open Government Partnership (OGP) initiated by American President Barack Obama is the establishment of a transparent, efficient and accountable government/administration. The HCLU and K-Monitor have prepared proposals on commitments to be undertaken by Hungary.